IB Biology SL 4.1.5 Evidence for Natural Selection
Practise evaluating survival curves and biological data to decide whether inherited traits provide an evolutionary advantage.
- Syllabus
- First assessment 2025
- Course
- Biology SL
- Level
- SL
Practise evaluating survival curves and biological data to decide whether inherited traits provide an evolutionary advantage.
The sickle-cell hemoglobin allele (Hbs) has a high frequency in regions where there is malaria. This is believed to be due to a selective advantage against fatal malaria for the heterozygote ( HbAHbs ). Individuals who are homozygous for the sickle cell allele ( HbsHbs ) have sickle cell anemia while heterozygotes have a much less severe form of the disease. Normal individuals without sickle cell anemia are designated HbAHbA.
This study involved 1022 children living in an area of Kenya where malaria is present. The possible protective effect of the sickle cell allele against mortality due to malaria was investigated. The data show the percentage of children surviving after birth over a period of 48 months.

Outline the pattern of survival for individuals homozygous for the sickle cell allele (HbsHbs).
a. overall decrease over time;
b. repeating pattern of periods of constant survival followed by drops;
c. constant up to about 3-4 months;
d. rapid decrease between 3/4 and 7/9 months;
e. remains fairly constant after 9 months / further drop at 24 months;
Marking guidance:
Accept numerical values in place of some statements.
Compare the patterns of survival for the HbAHbS and HbAHbA genotypes.
a. both decrease with time;
b. survival is similar / equal up to about 3 months;
c. (from about 3 months onwards) heterozygote /HbAHbS exceeds homozygote/ HbAHbA;
d. HbAHbA continues to decrease while HbAHbS levels off;
e. after about 15 months difference between survival rates remains about the same;