A4.1.3—Evidence from selective breeding

Selective breeding demonstrates that choosing parents with desired heritable traits can produce rapid, cumulative evolutionary change within domesticated populations over successive generations.

Syllabus
First assessment 2025
Objective
A4.1.3
Level
HL

Exam analysis

Chance of appearing3%of analysed past papers
Latest appearanceNovember 2023
Most common paperPaper1
Typical marks1–3

Common command terms

  • Outline

Scoring notes

Common mistake
Calling selective breeding natural selection when the selecting agent is human choice.

Recent exam appearances

November 2023Paper1 ["HL"] · TZ214[ 1 ]A4.1.3—Evidence from selective breeding
May 2023Paper1 ["HL"] · TZ217[ 1 ]A4.1.3—Evidence from selective breeding
November 2017Paper2 ["HL"] · TZ06(c)[ 3 ]A4.1.3—Evidence from selective breeding
Practice this objective

Coverage 2017–2023 · Updated 15 Jul 2026

Selective Breeding Demonstrates Heritable Variation

Artificial selection is evidence for evolution because humans repeatedly breed individuals with desired heritable traits, changing trait and allele frequencies across generations.

Domesticated animal breeds and crop varieties differ greatly from one another and from their original wild species. These changes can occur rapidly when strong selection acts on existing heritable variation.

A response requires variation in the trait, a heritable component, preferential reproduction of selected individuals and repeated selection. Correlated traits may also change because genes and traits are not always independent.

If farmers repeatedly propagate seeds from plants with a heritable high-yield trait, that trait can become more common over generations and the crop variety can diverge from its wild ancestor.

Selective breeding changes a population across generations; feeding one animal well can change its growth but is not inherited evolution. It also does not show that every trait is controlled by one gene.

Evidence from selective breeding

Assessment in practice

1 marks
How it is assessed

This objective is assessed through structured response, commonly using Outline.

Command terms

Outline

What earns marks

Build the answer around this relationship: Selective breeding is artificial selection for desired heritable traits.

Watch for

Calling selective breeding natural selection when the selecting agent is human choice.

Representative question

Question 1

[Maximum number: 3]

Outline the evidence for evolution provided by selective breeding.

SL Transfer: Evidence To Speciation

The core A4.1 answer moves from evidence to mechanism. Define evolution as heritable population change across generations. Use molecular universals and sequence differences, selective breeding, homology, and convergence as evidence for common ancestry and divergence. Then explain speciation as reduced gene flow followed by divergence of isolated gene pools through selection, mutation, and drift.

  • Evolution is cumulative change in heritable characteristics of a population.
  • Molecular evidence supports common ancestry and divergence.
  • Selective breeding shows heritable traits can change rapidly under selection.
  • Homology supports common ancestry; analogy/convergence shows similar selection pressures can mislead.
  • Speciation needs reduced gene flow and divergence of isolated gene pools.

Concept essentials

  • Selective breeding is artificial selection for desired heritable traits.
  • Domesticated forms can differ greatly from their wild ancestors after repeated selection.
  • Breeding evidence shows that inherited traits can change rapidly in a population.
  • The process supports evolution because selection changes trait frequencies across generations.