B.4.6 (HL)—Second law of thermodynamics
- Syllabus
- First assessment 2025
- Objective
- —
- Level
- HL
Second law
The entropy of an isolated system never decreases:
ΔSisolated≥0
Real spontaneous processes usually increase it.
Local decreases are allowed
A non-isolated subsystem can decrease in entropy, such as the contents of a refrigerator, but the surroundings must increase in entropy by at least as much. Judge the total isolated system.
Direction and engines
The second law gives the net direction of thermal transfer from hot to cold and prevents a heat engine from converting all input thermal energy into work. It leads to the Carnot efficiency limit.
Common trap
“Entropy never decreases” applies to an isolated system or the universe, not necessarily to every local subsystem.
The evidence asks why a real engine cannot exceed Carnot efficiency and checks a calculated engine efficiency against the Carnot limit.
Explain / Outline
Use the second law to state that total entropy of an isolated system cannot decrease. For engine questions, calculate or compare the Carnot limit before explaining why a real engine must have lower efficiency.
Claiming the second law forbids all local entropy decreases or saying efficiency can equal/exceed the Carnot limit for a real engine.
Representative question
Explain, by reference to the second law of thermodynamics, why a real engine operating between the temperatures of 620 K and 340 K cannot have an efficiency greater than the answer to (b)(i).
the Carnot cycle has the maximum efficiency « for heat engines operating between two given temperatures »
real engine can not work at Carnot cycle/ideal cycle the second law of thermodynamics says that it is impossible to convert all the input heat into mechanical work
a real engine would have additional losses due to friction etc
2 max