IB ESS HL 3.1 Biodiversity and Evolution Questions
Practise IB ESS HL 3.1 by analysing diversity indices and evidence for natural selection, isolation and speciation.
- Syllabus
- First assessment 2026
- Course
- ESS HL
- Level
- HL
Practise IB ESS HL 3.1 by analysing diversity indices and evidence for natural selection, isolation and speciation.
Figure:Extinction risk levels of species in global biodiversity by category
Figure:Changing species extinction risk by category 1980–2015
Figures 1(a) and 1(b) are based on records for species diversity. Identify one other factor that may be measured to assess the diversity of life on Earth.
a. genetic diversity;
b. habitat diversity;
Do not accept "evenness/equitability" or "richness" they are already included within concept of species diversity
Outline the mechanisms by which a terrestrial species may have evolved from an aquatic ancestor.
a. there was genetic variety in aquatic species/mutations accumulated over years;
b. certain features may have adaptation/advantage for terrestrial existence;
c. individuals with these features could colonize terrestrial habitat;
d. they would be more likely to survive/survival of the fittest/experience less competition (natural selection);
e. they produce offspring like themselves/feature will become more abundant;
f. individuals with feature may be unable to breed with others without feature /speciation occurs / reproductive/geographical barrier will give rise to new terrestrial species;
Explain the ways in which species diversity and an abundance of plant and herbivore species will increase the resilience of an ecosystem.
Diversity:
a. a greater diversity of plant and herbivore species would mean there are more species to take over the role of any that would be lost/creates a more complex food web;
b. a wider variety/diversity set of plant species will support a wider range of herbivores/increase habitat diversity;
c. a wider variety/diversity of plant species will be able to exploit a wider range of abiotic conditions;
d. more plant species/greater plant diversity will be more likely to include species that will survive a change in conditions;
e. a wider variety/diversity plant species will increase interspecific competition resulting in evolution of more species;
f. a wider variety/diversity of herbivorous species will support a wider range of predators;
g. a wider variety/diversity of herbivore species will occupy a wider range of niches adding to the complexity of the system;
Abundance:
h. a greater abundance/larger populations of plant species means greater primary productivity which supports a greater abundance/larger populations of herbivores;
i. a greater abundance/larger populations of plant species is less likely to become extinct from the ecosystem;
j. a greater abundance/larger populations of herbivores will support a greater abundance/larger populations of predators;
k. a greater abundance/larger populations of herbivores will be less likely to become extinct in the ecosystem;
Explain one natural and one human-caused factor that influences changes in biodiversity.
Natural factor [4 max]:
(Extinction)
a. mass extinctions of the past/local extinctions caused by various natural factors, have (temporarily) reduced biodiversity;
b. e.g. tectonic plate activity / super-volcanic eruption;
c. e.g. climatic changes (including drought and ice ages);
d. e.g. meteorite impacts;
(Evolution)
e. Evolution is a natural factor that has led to increased biodiversity;
f. Mutation leads to increases in genetic diversity;
g. Natural selection may lead to some reduction in genetic diversity;
h. Speciation has led to increased species diversity;
i. Adaptive radiation has led to increased speciation/genetic diversity;
Human caused factor [4 max]:
(Extinction)
j. human activity is considered to be causing a sixth mass extinction;
k. e.g. habitat destruction/deforestation/urbanisation;
l. e.g. pollution of freshwater water bodies/oceans/soils/atmosphere/leading to climate change/associated environmental hazards;
m. e.g. over-exploitation of resources/overfishing/hunting/intensive agriculture;
(Conservation)
n. conservation/restoration of ecosystems has led to increased biodiversity;
o. e.g. establishment of national parks/nature reserves etc.;
p. e.g. ex situ conservation/zoos/plantations/seed banks reduce loss of biodiversity;
q. e.g. legislation/trade agreements protecting species e.g. CITES/fishing quotas/endangered species act;
Explain the ways in which species diversity and an abundance of plant and herbivore species will increase the resilience of an ecosystem.
Diversity:
a. a greater diversity of plant and herbivore species would mean there are more species to take over the role of any that would be lost/creates a more complex food web;
b. a wider variety/diversity set of plant species will support a wider range of herbivores/increase habitat diversity;
c. a wider variety/diversity of plant species will be able to exploit a wider range of abiotic conditions;
d. more plant species/greater plant diversity will be more likely to include species that will survive a change in conditions;
e. a wider variety/diversity plant species will increase interspecific competition resulting in evolution of more species;
f. a wider variety/diversity of herbivorous species will support a wider range of predators;
g. a wider variety/diversity of herbivore species will occupy a wider range of niches adding to the complexity of the system;
Abundance:
h. a greater abundance/larger populations of plant species means greater primary productivity which supports a greater abundance/larger populations of herbivores;
i. a greater abundance/larger populations of plant species is less likely to become extinct from the ecosystem;
j. a greater abundance/larger populations of herbivores will support a greater abundance/larger populations of predators;
k. a greater abundance/larger populations of herbivores will be less likely to become extinct in the ecosystem;
Figure:Continents and species diversity over time
Outline the role of natural selection in increasing the diversity of species.
natural selection (resulting from changing environment) acts on existing genetic variation (that has arisen through mutations over the eons);
natural selection increases the survival of fittest genetic variations/traits;
these traits are heritable/passed onto offspring / selected individuals will have higher reproduction potential / so species will adapt to different environments;
the proportion of these traits may increase in some populations/in subsequent generations;
which can lead to speciation/increasing species diversity if there is reproductive isolation;
Figure:Fact file on Mindo cloud forest
Figure:Fact file on Mindo harlequin toad
There is no cure and those infected experience 85–100% mortality.
Explain how the disease in the Mindo harlequin toad could contribute to the evolution of resistance to this disease in the species for future generations.
a. Natural selection/survival of the fittest;
b. Random (genetic) mutations/variations in each generation would eventually produce some individuals with a (genetic) resistance to the fungus / The disease acts as a selection pressure, meaning only individuals with advantageous alleles survive;
c. Those that survive would produce offspring inheriting that same resistance;
d. Over many generations, the frequency of the resistance allele/gene increases in the population;
e. This leads to a population better suited to survive in environments where the fungus is present;
Note to examiners: do not accept responses which state that organisms adapt to the disease.
Explain how natural processes may lead to the formation of new species.
a. mutation/sexual reproduction increases genetic diversity in a population;
b. those individuals with (genetically determined) features best adapted/more fit to their habitat/environment;
c. ...will survive / survival of fittest;
d. ...and will reproduce more successfully / leave a larger number of offspring;
e. passing on to their offspring these favorable genes/traits;
f. favorable traits will dominate in population / gene frequency/genetic characteristics of a population changes over time;
g. a population may become divided due to plate tectonics/changing landscapes/ colonization of newly emerged habitats/islands;
h. ...leading to genetic isolation of parts/subpopulations;
i. the separated populations may undergo (divergent) evolution / under different selective pressures / in different habitats;
j. accumulating different mutations over generations;
k. the differences between separated populations may prevent them from interbreeding / when populations are unable to interbreed and produce fertile offspring they are considered separate species;
l. the process of natural selection led to speciation;
Credit may be gained through appropriate examples.
Figure:Four species of the family Leporidae
Figure:A dichotomous key for species A to D
Figure:Sagebrush ecosystem without invasive cheatgrass
Figure:Sagebrush ecosystem with invasive cheatgrass
The family Leporidae includes hares and rabbits. The figures show four species that can be found in western North America.
Distinguish between the biodiversity of the sagebrush ecosystems in Figures 1(c) and 1(d).
a. greater overall biodiversity without cheatgrass/in Figure 1(c);
b. greater habitat/species/genetic diversity without cheatgrass/Figure 1(c)
c. greater richness of species without cheatgrass/in Figure 1(c);
d. greater evenness of species without cheatgrass/in Figure 1(c);
Note: Accept in the converse
Figure:Eight freshwater organisms
Figure 2 shows eight freshwater organisms.
Table:Organisms sampled in streams A and B
The table shows data from sampling two streams: A and B. Calculate the Simpson’s Diversity Index for Stream B.
D=∑n(n−1)N(N−1)
You must show your working.
1(1−1)+4(4−1)+45(45−1)+100(100−1)150(150−1);
1.88/1.879/1.9;
Both top and bottom values of equation need to be correct to be credited mark for showing working out.
Figure:Conservation status of indigenous species groups in New Zealand
Suggest one reason why there is insufficient data available to categorise the conservation status of a large proportion of marine mammals, as shown in Figure 2(c).
a. Lack of expertise / lack of technology for underwater research;
b. Lack of existing relevant keys/identification resources;
c. Difficulty in identifying/sampling species in the water (due to turbidity/reduced visibility);
d. Species can be difficult to find in deep water / difficult to find species hiding on seabed/under rocks/within vegetation;
e. Large size of oceans so difficult to explore;
f. Species migrate making them difficult to find at certain times of the year / species are motile moving from one location to another and therefore difficult to identify;
g. Insufficient human resources;
Do not accept only 'difficult to access the water" or "some areas are inaccessible".
Do not accept "difficult to explore/find" without giving reason.
Do not accept only "migration".
Identify four reasons why the genetic diversity of a population may change over time.
mutation may lead to new genotypes/increased diversity;
natural selection/survival of fittest may eliminate some genotypes/reduce diversity;
(human activities) eg pollution/hunting/habitat destruction/alien species may reduce population/diversity / lead to a bottleneck effect;
migration causing mixing of populations/subjection to new selective pressures;
climate change may eliminate certain genotypes/reduce diversity; ...or lead to evolution of new genotypes/increase diversity;
(tectonic activity may create) natural barriers leading to divergent evolution/speciation/greater diversity;
genetic drift/random loss of genes;
mixing of GMOs/selectively bred/farmed escapees introduces new genes to wild populations;
Marking guidance:
Accept any other reasonable suggestions.
Responses that identify relevant factors eg "mutation", but do not identify why/how this influences diversity should not gain full credit.
Award [1 max] for responses that list three valid factors without identifying how they influence diversity.
Award [2 max] for responses that identify four such factors.
Award [1] for each correct reason identified, up to [4 max].
Figure:Conservation status of indigenous species groups in New Zealand
Figure:Proportion of New Zealand species that are endemic
Figure 2(a): Fact file on biodiversity in New Zealand
New Zealand is a geographically isolated island system which became separated from the southern supercontinent 85 million years ago. It has many endemic species, including flightless birds such as Kiwi, Kākāpō and Takahē, which evolved in the absence of terrestrial ground predators.
Outline two factors that may have contributed to the large number of species only found within New Zealand.
a. Geographical isolation/isolation from other land masses (leading to speciation);
b. Process of natural selection/evolution/species evolve (leading to speciation);
c. Diverse geographical conditions / variation in altitude / variation in presence of water;
d. Diverse climate allowing for development of different habitats/ecosystems/biomes / presence of different habitats/ecosystems/biomes (lead to large variety of species);
e. Adaptive radiation to the distinctive New Zealand environment (e.g. complete absence of indigenous terrestrial ground predators);
Do not accept only "species have adapted to absence of terrestrial predators".
Do not accept reference to only one biome e.g. rainforest.
Do not accept only "different types of vegetation".
Explain why Ecuador supports a high level of biodiversity.
a. Wide variation in topography/altitude allows for range of ecosystems/habitats/ecological niches;
b. Variation in climatic conditions leads to a range of ecosystems/habitats/ecological niches;
c. Wide range of biomes/ecosystems/habitats (e.g. marine and terrestrial) lead to high levels of biodiversity/large number of species;
d. Wide range of biomes/ecosystems/habitats allows for wide variety of ecological niches;
e. Geographical isolation (e.g. due to mountains) in Ecuador limits competition from non-native species (and preserves high biodiversity);
f. Geographical isolation leads to speciation and increased diversity;
g. Tropical location allows for high levels of precipitation/insolation/warm temperatures leading to high levels of primary productivity/photosynthesis (that supports high biodiversity);
Note to examiners: Do not accept only "wide range of biomes/ecosystems/habitats" without direct reference to high biodiversity.
Figure:Distribution of two peppered-moth forms
Figure 4 shows the distribution of two forms of peppered moths in woodlands of the UK in the 1950s. At the time, surfaces of most trees in Central and South Eastern England were heavily blackened with deposits of carbon from local coal burning. There are two forms of the moth, dark and light, and both may be eaten by woodland birds.
Describe the relationship between the distribution of the two forms of moths and habitat pollution.
darker peppered moths where the air pollution is highest;
light peppered moths where there is less air pollution;
Suggest one reason to explain the relationship you have identified in (b)(i).
Light-coloured moths are adapted to non polluted trees in non-polluted areas and do not stand out/are better able to hide from their predators/are camouflaged;
Dark moths are adapted to soot covered trees/buildings in polluted areas and do not stand out/are better able to hide from their predators/are camouflaged;
Each population will tend to survive, through natural selection, and produce descendants / WTTE;
The graph shows past mass extinctions.
Explain one factor that may make a species less prone to extinction.
reach sexual maturity early;
...which means they are able to produce offspring early/have more offspring/have larger populations (and increase their species chances of success);
they can have high reproductive success/produce large number of offspring; ...large populations can increase the chances of their survival;
they are opportunistic/r species able to adapt to a wide variety of conditions; ...this allows them to be present in many habitats / have wide geographical coverage;
they have fast lifecycles (e.g. r species);
...which allows them to adapt quickly to change;
they have a number of habitats they can shelter/live/ are widely distributed; ...so if a population is affected in one habitat (e.g. by disease/predation) the species will still survive in another habitat/location;
they are omnivores/generalist feeders/switching predators;
...this adaptability to eating different foods results in potentially a large available food source/with some food source available even under harsh conditions;
ability to hide/camouflage/successfully fight;
...which can reduce predation rates and increase chances of species survival;
have high genetic diversity;
...they are able to adapt to changing environmental conditions;
valued by humans (e.g. as keystone/flagship species);
..increases human investment/action into conserving the species/its habitat (e.g. Giant Panda);
not considered valuable by humans (e.g. as pets or making ornaments);
...it is not hunted/removed from habitat thereby reducing risk of extinction;
Marking guidance:
Award 1 mark for identifying the factor and 1 mark for the explanation.
Accept other reasonable responses.
Explain how the movement of tectonic plates has influenced biodiversity and evolution.
a. plate tectonic movement may lead to divergence of continents/growth of mountain ranges/opening of oceans/formation of islands...;
b. ...which separates populations/species from each other/isolates gene pools...;
c. ...leading to divergent evolution/action of natural selection/genetic drift / accumulating different mutations over (geological) time...;
d. ...as they have to adapt to different habitats/climates/environmental pressures (in order for fitter species to survive)...
e. ...causing speciation (thus, increasing biodiversity);
f. ...or may shift population in harsher climatic/habitat conditions, causing their extinction (thus reducing biodiversity);
g. plate tectonic movement may lead to formation of land bridges / closing of oceans…;
h. ...which brings different populations/species in contact / opens novel migration routes...;
i. ...leading to interspecific competition / competitive niche exclusion...;
j. ...which might cause the extinction of less fit species (reducing biodiversity);
k. ...also leading to hybridization/interbreeding of related species / increased gene exchange/flow...;
l. ...which may either reduce genetic differences / lump related species (thus, reducing biodiversity);
m. ...or create a new species better adapted to intermediate/new habitat/ e.g. introgression in plants (thus, increasing biodiversity);
Note: Do NOT credit description of evolutionary process (mutations / natural selection / survival of fittest / fitter genes dominating a population / speciation) outside the context of plate tectonics movement.
The graph shows past mass extinctions.
Identify two ways in which the current extinction differs from mass extinctions in the past.
rate of change is faster/happening over a shorter time frame;
caused by another species changing the environment/not caused by natural phenomena as in the past/caused by humans;
humans can prevent current extinction;