IB ESS HL 4.4 Water Pollution Questions
Practise IB ESS HL 4.4 by analysing direct tests, biotic indices and WQI evidence and evaluating pollution controls and coordinated action.
- Syllabus
- First assessment 2026
- Course
- ESS HL
- Level
- HL
Practise IB ESS HL 4.4 by analysing direct tests, biotic indices and WQI evidence and evaluating pollution controls and coordinated action.
A small lake is going through the process of eutrophication. State one possible point source and one possible non-point source of nutrient pollution in the lake.
Point source:
Non-point source:
point source: sewage outfall/effluent pipe;
non-point source: agricultural/erosion/run-off/leaching of fertilizers in a large area;
Marking guidance:
Do not accept acid rain.
Define the term biochemical oxygen demand (BOD).
a measure of the amount of dissolved oxygen required to break down the organic material (in a given volume of water through aerobic biological activity);
Figure:pH-tolerance ranges of freshwater organisms
The pH-tolerance chart shows the ranges over which aquatic organisms in a small lake can survive.
Use the pH-tolerance ranges of freshwater organisms: the pH tolerance ranges of trout, bass, perch, frogs, salamanders, clams, crayfish, snails and mayfly in the small lake.
State which organism(s) would still be present if the pH of the lake was reduced to 5.0.
trout, perch, salamanders and frogs;
All four required to award [1].
Use the pH-tolerance ranges of freshwater organisms: the pH tolerance ranges of trout, bass, perch, frogs, salamanders, clams, crayfish, snails and mayfly in the small lake.
Explain why the populations of remaining organisms in the lake may decline in the long term.
these species will be at the limits of their tolerance;
may have reduced health;
may have reduced reproductive success;
these species are relatively high in the food chain;
loss of food species;
may be exposed to additional pollutants e.g. heavy metals;
Allow any other reasonable suggestions. Award [2 max].
Many countries produce large amounts of solid domestic waste. Pacific Ocean currents concentrate and trap solid domestic waste from the Pacific Rim countries and have created the Great Pacific Garbage Patch (GPGP) in the North Pacific Gyre (Figure 5).
Figure 6:Consumption and disposal of plastic waste for India and selected Pacific Rim countries
* Estimated for 2017 based on 10% growth.
Identify one reason why most plastics may be considered more serious pollutants than other forms of solid domestic waste.
plastics produced in huge quantities/very widespread (due to usefulness/versatility);
plastics are non-biodegradable / may take hundreds of years to fully degrade / generational problem;
marine animals may be killed through entanglement/suffocation/ingestion leading to starvation;
degraded smaller particles can be easily and widely dispersed;
degraded plastic may become more toxic by absorbing other toxins/releasing POPs;
microparticles can be absorbed by species causing biomagnification/damage to food chains;
Explain why the data in Figure 6 show no correlation between plastic consumption and plastic waste deposited in ocean for the countries listed.
laws/policies against depositing plastic in sea may be less stringent/well-enforced in some countries (eg China);
some countries may have greater discharge from rivers into sea (eg China);
some countries may have greater population densities near to coast (eg India/China);
some countries may have more efficient garbage disposal/recycling systems (eg Japan/USA);
industrialisation involving plastic production/use may have higher priority in some countries (eg China/India);
estimated data may be inaccurate/unrepresentative/based on false assumptions;
data may be politically biased/not verified independently;
Part (c) questions in Section B are all to be assessed using the markbands on page 18 with the guidance given below for each question.
Figure:Coliform bacteria one day after untreated sewage release
Using Figure 11(b), estimate the highest concentrations of coliform bacteria (in units/100 mL) found in the St Lawrence River one day after the untreated sewage was released.
120000 (units / 100 ml );
Units are not required.
Outline an environmental problem that may result from the release of untreated sewage into a river.
• Eutrophication / algal bloom — due to high levels of nitrates and phosphates/nutrients.
• Hypoxic conditions — due to high oxygen demand.
• Rotten egg smell / production of hydrogen sulphide — due to anaerobic decomposition.
• Increase in micro-organisms/pathogens within shellfish — due to pathogens being filtered out of the water.
• Ill health in people / increase in waterborne disease — from eating shellfish/fish contaminated with pathogens/bacteria (from sewage), swimming in water contaminated with pathogens/bacteria (from sewage), or drinking water contaminated with pathogens/bacteria.
• Death/loss of benthic species — due to particulates blocking feeding/respiratory systems.
• Decrease in photosynthesis — due to increase in turbidity (reducing light penetration).
Accept any other reasonable response. Answer must have the named problem and the associated outline for both marks.
Do not accept 'thermal pollution/increase in temperature'.
Do not accept just 'loss of biodiversity / water unsuitable for human use'.
Figure:Coliform bacteria before untreated sewage release
Montreal:
In November 2015, the City of Montreal discharged between 5 and 8 billion litres of untreated sewage into the St Lawrence River.
• It was called “FlushGate” in the Canadian news.
• Citizens were warned to avoid contact with the water.
• River pollution levels returned to normal within 4 to 10 days.
• The Mayor of Montreal described it as the “most environmentally-friendly solution”.
Quebec:
In November 2016, the City of Quebec discharged 110 million litres of untreated sewage into the St Lawrence River.
Nationally:
• 25 % of Canadians do not have access to sewage or wastewater treatment centres.
• 205 billion litres of untreated sewage are released into Canadian rivers and oceans each year.
With reference to Figures 10, 11(a) and 11(b), describe a method to monitor the impact of the release of untreated sewage into the St Lawrence River ecosystem.
can use indirect or direct measures of pollution;
direct measurements of dissolved oxygen using a probe / light and dark bottle method to measure BOD / direct counts of coliform units using microscopes / Secchi disc to monitor turbidity / titration to measure changes in nitrates/phosphates;
freshwater invertebrates can be used as indicator species;
compare with historic data / take measurements before the release of the untreated sewage (for 'normal' measurements);
take measurements along the length of the river, from the point source downstream (to determine area impacted);
take measurements over a period of time, to observe changes in water quality;