IB ESS HL 2.5 Zonation Succession and Change Questions
Analyse transect and succession evidence, explain productivity and community development, and assess climax and plagioclimax concepts.
- Syllabus
- First assessment 2026
- Course
- ESS HL
- Level
- HL
Analyse transect and succession evidence, explain productivity and community development, and assess climax and plagioclimax concepts.
Figure:Salinity variation in the Large Ocean Management Area
Figure:Water-surface temperature variation across the LOMA
Figure:temperature scale
Suggest one reason for the zonation seen in Figure 5(b).
depth of water / shallow water is warmer / shallow water is easier to warm up / deep water is cooler;
position in relation to land / distance from land;
latitude / distance from equator / northern areas are cooler / southern areas are warmer;
cold ocean currents (Labrador) coming down from the north and warm ocean currents (Gulf Stream) coming up from the south;
Marking guidance:
Do not accept 'climate change / global warming / variation in climate / salinity / temperature'.
Figure:Beaver-dam succession sequence — panel A
Figure:Beaver-dam succession sequence — panel B
Figure:Beaver-dam succession sequence — panel C
Figure:Beaver-dam succession sequence — panel D
Suggest how an ecologist might measure the changes in one abiotic factor along a transect from a beaver marsh, through beaver meadow to the adjoining forest.
use appropriate method/sampling device for identified abiotic factor eg use of thermometer to measure soil or air temperature / pH probe to measure pH value of soil / light sensor to measure light intensity / soil test kits to measure concentration of nutrients/nitrates/phosphates / hygrometer to measure humidity / use of soil moisture sensor/tensiometer / soil texture using different mesh size sieves;
use systematic sampling/interrupted belt transect/ take readings at regular intervals along transect;
repeat readings to obtain averages/increase reliability /take multiple readings to obtain average/increase reliability;
Figure:Stages of ecological succession after fire
Outline two reasons why the species within pioneer communities in the succession model shown above are more likely to be r-strategists than K-strategists.
r-strategists produce greater numbers/many offspring/fast population growth;
r-strategists distribute themselves more widely/colonize more quickly;
r-strategists mature quickly/reproduce earlier/establish themselves faster;
r-strategists better adapted to harsh/low-nutrient conditions/less specialised niches;
Do not accept just ANY valid characteristic of r-strategists (eg short life-span) ...only those directly relevant to a pioneer community as above.
Outline two reasons why the climax community in the succession model shown above is more stable than the intermediate community.
greater number of species/habitat/ecological niches/genetic diversity in climax community;
gross productivity/stored biomass is higher in climax community;
more complex/diverse energy pathways/food webs;
more established nutrient cycling;
more favourable abiotic conditions/soil properties;
more established negative feedback mechanisms;
Distinguish between zonation and succession.
succession is the process of changes in community/ecosystem over time, whereas zonation is the process of changes over an environmental gradient/space;
Outline two ways in which the food web is likely to change as a result of succession.
increasing numbers of trophic levels / longer food chains;
will be composed of new/different species;
more branching / greater complexity / more species at each trophic level;
greater gross productivity/energy transferred at each trophic level;
more biomass stored at each trophic level;
increased prominence of decomposer community;
Outline two ways in which the soil quality in the pioneer stages of the succession model shown above will differ from that in the climax ecosystem.
In pioneer communities:
there will be lower organic content/leaf litter (due to combustion from the fire);
there may be a higher concentration of available minerals (released from ashes);
there may be fewer soil organisms (following deaths from fire);
it will be more prone to erosion/evaporation losses (through lack of vegetation cover/roots by fire);
less established nutrient recycling / reduced decomposer community;
Accept converse of these statements for climax community.
Note: The model shows SECONDARY succession (after fire), so not all generic features of a pioneer community in PRIMARY succession would be valid. eg in primary succession soil nutrients may be higher in climax community, but in secondary succession reverse is more likely (although processes of nutrient cycling/decomposition may still be more advanced established in climax community as in primary succession).
Figure:Stages of ecological succession after fire
Distinguish between zonation and succession.
succession is the process of changes in community/ecosystem over time, whereas zonation is the process of changes over an environmental gradient/space;
Identify four differences between a climax community and a pioneer community.
Climax community has:
a. Greater species diversity/biodiversity;
b. Greater habitat diversity / more niches;
c. Longer food chains / more branched food webs;
d. Greater nutrient cycling / larger decomposer community;
e. Deeper/more developed soil;
f. Greater GPP/biomass/storages of energy;
g. Greater community respiration;
h. More K selected species;
i. (Often) woody shrubs/trees/larger animals whereas pioneer might be more characterised by lichens/mosses etc.
j. Greater resilience (due to the increased complexity);
Note to examiners: Accept converse statements.
Figure:An example of a retreating glacier in the Swiss Alps, 1891 (left) and 2019 (right)
Figure:Average percent cover vegetation near a glacier
Describe the processes leading to the development of a pioneer community as the glacier retreats, as shown in Figures 4(c) and 4(d).
a. Primary succession / succession on bare rock / lithosere;
b. Physical factors (temperature, precipitation, freeze-thaw weathering) weather/erode bare rock (creating the mineral/abiotic component/soil base);
c. Plants/seeds/early colonizing species/pioneer species are brought in by wind/animals/birds;
d. Early colonising/pioneer species/r-selected/r-strategist/r-species become established/spread rapidly;
e. Early colonising/pioneer species/leguminous/plants add organic matter/nutrient content/improve soil quality (as they decompose);
f. Root systems of early colonizers help to stabilize the soil layer/reduce erosion;
g. As soil depth increases, more plants can survive/percent cover vegetation increases;
Note to examiners: Do not credit responses that refer to climax communities.
Figure 4(a): Fact file on giant sequoia (Sequoiadendron giganteum) trees
Giant sequoias are legally protected in California. They are adapted to periodic fire; historically, wildfires have occurred in California every 6-35 years. They have thick bark up to 46 cm to protect the core from fire. Fire dries cones and releases seeds, while ash creates nutrient-rich soils. Seeds can also be released by the long-horned beetle, which lays eggs in cones; larvae eat the cone, releasing seeds.
Describe the process of succession after a wildfire has occurred in the forest.
a. removal of trees open the canopy, allowing sunlight to reach the forest floor/removing limiting factor of shade conditions;
b. burning trees produce nutrient-rich ash increasing soil fertility;
c. growth of seeds which survived the fire/released by the fire/were blown/carried in from surrounding unburnt areas;
d. rapid growth of annual plants / in early stages of succession there are pioneer species/r-selected species;
e. replaced in time by slower growing species / change from r-selected species to K-selected species;
f. climax community of (coniferous) forest reached after many years;
g. large time delay due to slow growth of climax community;
h. each new sere changes the abiotic conditions, allowing for different plants to survive / as conditions change some species will outcompete/replace others;
Figure:Distribution of birch forest in Iceland in 874 and 2015
Figure:Soil erosion in Iceland in 2007
Figure:Stages of soil degradation and vegetation-cover change in Iceland
Figure:Known distribution of Nootka lupin in 2010
With reference to Figures: Distribution of birch forest in Iceland in 874 and 2015, Soil erosion in Iceland in 2007, Stages of soil degradation and vegetation-cover change in Iceland and Known distribution of Nootka lupin in 2010 identify two ways in which vegetation cover has changed over time in Iceland.
vegetation cover has been significantly reduced;
change from woodlands to heath/moor/shrubs/desertified/bare landscape;
extent of birch forest has reduced (significantly/by more than half);
increase in coverage of lupins;
lupins replace/outcompete native flora;
Marking guidance:
Do not accept change from 'vegetation cover to desertified landscape'
Figure:Stages of ecological succession after fire
Outline two reasons why the climax community in the succession model shown above is more stable than the intermediate community.
greater number of species/habitat/ecological niches/genetic diversity in climax community;
gross productivity/stored biomass is higher in climax community;
more complex/diverse energy pathways/food webs;
more established nutrient cycling;
more favourable abiotic conditions/soil properties;
more established negative feedback mechanisms;
Outline one climatic and one edaphic (soil) factor which affect the final climax community in an ecosystem.
Climatic:
amount of precipitation / insolation / (mean) temperature;
limit primary productivity/rate of photosynthesis that will determine the available biomass/food base/on which climax community will depend;
Edaphic:
soil depth / mineral content/amount of N/P/K / soil compaction/aeration / soil particle size / balance between clay, silt and sand / percolation rate / soil pH;
determine the particular vegetation types/plant species adapted to those conditions that support the climax community;
Marking guidance:
Award up to [2 max] for climatic factor and up to [2 max] for edaphic factor.
Explain how the process of succession leads to changes in productivity.
General:
a. GPP continues to increase throughout the successional stages due to increasing nutrient cycling / improved soil fertility/nutrients leads to greater productivity;
b. NP as a proportion of GP decreases throughout the stages due to increasing respiration from consumers/decomposers;
In primary succession/pioneer community:
c. Abiotic conditions are poor/nutrient levels are low so GPP is low;
d. NP of the community is high/NP as a proportion of the GP is high due to low consumption/respiration;
In intermediate stages:
e. Secondary productivity increases as consumers join food chain;
f. NP/increase in biomass of entire community slows due to consumption of GPP/increased respiratory losses by consumers;
In climax community/final stages
g. Secondary productivity is at maximum as food chains are fully developed;
h. GPP is at maximum due to plant communities reaching carrying capacity;
i. No NP/biomass gains for community as a whole as all PP being consumed/lost to respiration;
Figure A:Round goby (Neogobius melanostomus)
Figure B:Mottled sculpin (Cottus bairdii)
• An invasive species from Asia.
• First discovered in the St Lawrence River in 1990.
• Females lay eggs three times a year; up to 5000 eggs at a time.
• Young fish mature quickly.
• Can eat up to 4000 eggs of other fish in 15 minutes.
• Aggressively defend the best egg-laying sites, out-competing the native mottled sculpin (Cottus bairdii).
• Eat invasive zebra mussels.
• Eaten by native fish, such as lake trout and yellow perch.
Using Figures 9(a) and 9(b), identify one feature of the round goby that shows it is an r-selected species.
frequent egg laying ( 3 times per year);
many eggs laid at one time (5000);
young fish grow quickly / early maturity;
Figure:Rainforest environmental cartoon
Figure 5 shows an environmental cartoon about rainforests.
Define the term climax community.
community of organisms that is more or less stable, and that is in equilibrium with natural environmental conditions (such as climate) / the end point of ecological succession / WTTE;
A group of researchers want to investigate succession in an ecosystem.
Describe how two human factors could affect succession.
clearance of land for agriculture;
holding it in an early stage of succession / plagiosere;
grazing of land by livestock;
trampling from tourism;
human activities (eg tourism) leading to fires;
pollution from named human activities (eg mining);
introduction of plant/weed species/change to vegetation from near agricultural land;
Note: Do not award mark for statements such as "fire", "agriculture" without appropriate reason.