IB Physics HL E 5 Fusion and Stars Questions
Practise IB Physics HL E.5 by analysing stellar fusion chains, binding energy, spectra and quantitative star-property evidence.
- Syllabus
- First assessment 2025
- Course
- Physics HL
- Level
- HL
Practise IB Physics HL E.5 by analysing stellar fusion chains, binding energy, spectra and quantitative star-property evidence.
The diagram shows a simplified energy-balance model for the Earth surface-atmosphere system.
The following data are given:
The primary energy source of the Sun is the proton-proton (p-p) chain of fusion reactions. Four protons and two electrons produce a helium nucleus together with neutrinos and gamma photons. The overall reaction is:
Outline the role of fusion reactions in maintaining a stable radius of the Sun.
<<Photons emitted>> in fusion give rise to outward/ thermal/radiation pressure
Which prevents the Sun from collapsing due to <<inward>> gravitational forces
For MP1, outward/thermal/ radiation pressure must be linked to fusion
reactions
The positions of the Sun and the star Antares are shown in the Hertzsprung-Russell (HR) diagram.
State the star type of Antares.
«red» supergiant
Marking guidance:
Do not allow 'red giant'.
Discuss how nuclear fusion processes in Antares are different from those in the Sun.
The Sun only fuses hydrogen <<to helium>>
OR
Antares allows heavier elements «than hydrogen» to be fused
OR
Antares has fusion up to iron
Fusion in Antares occurs at a greater rate «because of greater mass/later evolutionary stage»
OR
Fusion in Antares requires a higher «core» temperature/density «because of greater mass/later evolutionary stage»
Antares has regions/shells where different elements are fused «due to its late evolutionary stage»
MP1 is about what is fusing to what
Marking guidance:
Do not allow ECF from white dwarf for MP1
MP2 is about fusion rate/conditions for fusion
MP3 is about where fusion occurs
Three stars A, B and C are labelled on the Hertzsprung-Russell (HR) diagram. L⊙ is the Luminosity of the sun.
State the main element that is undergoing nuclear fusion in star C .
Hydrogen
White dwarfs with similar volumes to each other are shown on the HR diagram.
Construct a line, on the HR diagram, to show the possible positions of other white dwarf stars with similar volumes to those marked on the HR diagram.
Any evidence of correct identification that three dots bottom left represent white dwarfs
line passing through all 3 white dwarfs OR line continuing from 3 white dwarfs with approximately same gradient, in either direction
Award MP2 if no line drawn through the three dots but just beyond them in either direction
Star A is a main sequence star.
The data for Star A and the Sun are given in a table.
State how physical stability is maintained in main sequence stars.
The outward «radiation/thermal» pressure/force is balanced by the «inward» gravitational pressure/force
Need to see reference to gravitational force/pressure. Do
not accept "gravity".
Explain why nuclear fusion in the core of the star occurs when the temperature and density exceed threshold values.
Nuclei need to have sufficiently high speed/energy to overcome repulsive force
Nuclei need to be sufficiently close for the strong nuclear force to cause attraction
Calculate, in m , the distance to Star A from Earth.
d=(0.741)(3.26)(9.46×1015)=4.2×1016 m
Distance must be stated in
metres.
The diagram shows a simplified energy-balance model for the Earth surface-atmosphere system.
The following data are given:
The primary energy source of the Sun is the proton-proton (p-p) chain of fusion reactions. Four protons and two electrons produce a helium nucleus together with neutrinos and gamma photons. The overall reaction is:
Outline the role of fusion reactions in maintaining a stable radius of the Sun.
<<Photons emitted>> in fusion give rise to outward/ thermal/radiation pressure
Which prevents the Sun from collapsing due to <<inward>> gravitational forces
For MP1, outward/thermal/ radiation pressure must be linked to fusion
reactions
Three stars A, B and C are labelled on the Hertzsprung-Russell (HR) diagram. L⊙ is the Luminosity of the sun.
State the main element that is undergoing nuclear fusion in star C .
Hydrogen
Star A is a main sequence star.
The data for Star A and the Sun are given in a table.
Explain why nuclear fusion in the core of the star occurs when the temperature and density exceed threshold values.
Nuclei need to have sufficiently high speed/energy to overcome repulsive force
Nuclei need to be sufficiently close for the strong nuclear force to cause attraction
Alpha Centauri A and B form the closest binary star system to the Earth. This binary star system is the third brightest stellar object in the night sky.
Proxima Centauri is a main sequence star with a mass of 0.12M⊙.
Compare the times for which Proxima Centauri and Alpha Centauri A are main sequence stars.
«L=E/t and E proportional to M so» t inversely proportional to M2.5
OR
tαtP=(0.121.12)2.5
OR faster fusion rate to hydrogen available in Alpha Centauri A
Proxima Centauri stays longer on main sequence OR
tP=270tα
Award [1] for a correct but incomplete reason, e.g. larger luminosity, or smaller mass, with the correct conclusion.
Explain the relationship between binary star systems and type I a supernovae.
type I a supernovae form when a white dwarf in a binary star system accretes mass from companion
The diagram shows a simplified energy-balance model for the Earth surface-atmosphere system.
The following data are given:
The positions of the Sun and the star Antares are shown in the Hertzsprung-Russell (HR) diagram.
State the star type of Antares.
«red» supergiant
Marking guidance:
Do not allow 'red giant'.
Star A is a main sequence star.
The data for Star A and the Sun are given in a table.
Calculate, in m , the distance to Star A from Earth.
d=(0.741)(3.26)(9.46×1015)=4.2×1016 m
Distance must be stated in
metres.
Alpha Centauri A and B is a binary star system in the main sequence.
The luminosity of the Sun is 3.8×1026 W. Calculate the radius of Alpha Centauri A.
r=5.67×10−8×4π×580041.5×3.8×1026=8.4×108 m
Show, without calculation, that the radius of Alpha Centauri B is smaller than the radius of Alpha Centauri A.
A=σT4L;
B and A have similar temperatures.
Therefore, their areas are in the ratio of their luminosities, so the radius of B is less than that of A.