Official holistic scoring rubric
This question is scored in four sections. Section 1 consists of part (a), section 2 of part (b), section 3 of parts (c) and (d), and section 4 of part (e). Each section is classified as essentially correct (E), partially correct (P), or incorrect (I).
Section 1: E requires all three components: a comparison of center or location, a comparison of variability, and comments in context. P requires exactly two components. Otherwise the section is I. Comparing only a few years or only the 1997 and 2010 endpoints is not a distribution comparison.
Section 2: E requires both the overall decreasing trend for the Western Pacific and the relatively constant or slightly increasing overall trend for the Eastern Pacific. P requires only one trend, or lists changes for both regions without identifying both overall trends. Otherwise the section is I.
Section 3: E requires all four components: appropriate calculations, the value 25.25, correct placement in the table, and appropriate placement in Graph B. P requires two or three components. Otherwise the section is I. A plotted value must be near 2010 and at or slightly above the 25-frequency line.
Section 4: E requires all three components: an overall trend from the moving-average graph in at least one region, a characteristic made less apparent by omitting individual yearly frequencies, and a link from at least one of those components to this specific time plot. P requires exactly two components. Otherwise the section is I.
Each E section counts as 1 point and each P section counts as one-half point. Scores are reported holistically as 4 (complete), 3 (substantial), 2 (developing), or 1 (minimal); a response between two scores is rounded according to overall strength and communication.