2.3.1 - Measures of economic performance

Syllabus
2018
Topic
2.3.1
Level
AS

Learning objectives

2.3.11a - rate of change of real Gross Domestic Product (GDP) as a measure of economic growth andThe rate of change of real Gross Domestic Product (GDP) as a measure of economic growth and living standards.2.3.11b - Gross National Income (GNI) as an alternative measure of national incomeGross National Income (GNI) as an alternative measure of national income.2.3.11c - distinction between the following measures of GDP/GNI: • real and nominal • total andThe distinction between the following measures of GDP/GNI:; real and nominal; total and per capita; value and volume.2.3.11d - Comparison of GDP/GNI rates of growth between countries and over timeComparison of GDP/GNI rates of growth between countries and over time.2.3.11e - concept of Purchasing Power Parities (PPPs) in making international comparisons of realThe concept of Purchasing Power Parities (PPPs) in making international comparisons of real GDP/GNI.2.3.11f - distinction between positive economic growth rates and negative economic growth ratesThe distinction between positive economic growth rates and negative economic growth rates.2.3.11g - concept of 'recession' as two consecutive quarters of negative economic growthThe concept of 'recession' as two consecutive quarters of negative economic growth.2.3.11h - limitations of using GDP/GNI to compare living standards between countries and over timeThe limitations of using GDP/GNI to compare living standards between countries and over time.2.3.11i - National happiness and wellbeing: • indicators of national happiness and wellbeing •National happiness and wellbeing:; indicators of national happiness and wellbeing; the relationship between real incomes and subjective happiness.2.3.12a - concepts of inflation, deflation and disinflationThe concepts of inflation, deflation and disinflation.2.3.12b - Calculating inflation using a consumer price index (CPI), including role of weightedCalculating inflation using a consumer price index (CPI), including role of weighted basket of goods and services.2.3.12c - Limitations of the CPI as a measure of the rate of inflationLimitations of the CPI as a measure of the rate of inflation.2.3.12d - producer (wholesale) price index as an indicator of future trends in the rate ofThe producer (wholesale) price index as an indicator of future trends in the rate of inflation.2.3.12e - Causes of inflation: • demand-pull • cost-push • excessive growth of money supplyCauses of inflation:; demand-pull; cost-push; excessive growth of money supply.2.3.12f - Causes of deflation: • falling aggregate demand (AD) • increase in aggregate supplyCauses of deflation:; falling aggregate demand (AD); increase in aggregate supply (AS); fall in the money supply.2.3.12g - Effects of inflation and deflation on: (continued) • Consumers • the government • firmsEffects of inflation and deflation on: (continued); Consumers; the government; firms; workers; income distribution; investment; competitiveness; the current account of the balance of payments.2.3.13a - unemployment is measured, using the International Labour unemployment OrganizationHow unemployment is measured, using the International Labour unemployment Organization (ILO) definition.2.3.13b - causes of unemployment: • frictional • seasonal • structural • demand deficiency • realThe causes of unemployment:; frictional; seasonal; structural; demand deficiency; real wage inflexibility.2.3.13c - effects of unemployment on: • consumers • firms • workers • public finances • resourceThe effects of unemployment on:; consumers; firms; workers; public finances; resource utilisation and production possibility frontier; society.2.3.13d - distinction between unemployment and underemploymentThe distinction between unemployment and underemployment.2.3.13e - significance of changes in rates of employment, unemployment and economic inactivityThe significance of changes in rates of employment, unemployment and economic inactivity.2.3.13f - significance of net migration for employment and unemploymentThe significance of net migration for employment and unemployment.2.3.14a - Components of the balance of payments, with particular payments reference to theComponents of the balance of payments, with particular payments reference to the current account.2.3.14b - distinction between deficits and surpluses in the trade in goods and services balanceThe distinction between deficits and surpluses in the trade in goods and services balance.2.3.14c - distinction between balance of payments deficits and surpluses on the current accountThe distinction between balance of payments deficits and surpluses on the current account.

Real GDP growth and living standards

Economic growth is the percentage increase in real GDP: the inflation-adjusted value of goods and services produced within an economy. growth=(real GDPtreal GDPt1)/real GDPt1×100growth=(real\ GDP_t-real\ GDP_{t-1})/real\ GDP_{t-1}\times100.

Growth can raise material living standards when it increases real output and real income per person, supporting consumption, employment and tax-funded services.

Total real GDP can grow while real GDP per capita falls if population grows faster. Growth is therefore evidence about material capacity, not a complete measure of wellbeing.

GDP and GNI

Measure Boundary
GDP output produced inside the country's territory, regardless of who owns the factors
GNI income received by the country's residents from production, wherever it occurs

GNI=GDP+net primary income from abroadGNI = GDP + net\ primary\ income\ from\ abroad. Net primary income is residents' income received from overseas minus income paid overseas to non-residents.

GNI is not GDP plus all exports. Exports are already part of domestic production; only the relevant cross-border primary-income balance converts GDP to GNI.

Choosing a GDP or GNI measure

Distinction First measure Second measure
nominal vs real current prices; price changes remain constant prices; inflation removed
total vs per capita whole economy total divided by population
value vs volume monetary worth quantity of output, holding prices constant

For living-standard change, prefer real per-capita data: deflate nominal output and then divide by population. GDP per capita=GDP/populationGDP\ per\ capita=GDP/population. Preserve units when moving between billions and millions.

Nominal growth can reflect inflation rather than more output; total growth can reflect population rather than more output per person.

Comparing economic growth

Use the same measure, price basis, currency treatment and time interval. Compare percentage growth rates rather than raw changes when economies begin at different sizes, and distinguish a one-period movement from a sustained trend.

Check Why it matters
real rather than nominal removes different inflation rates
per capita where living standards are compared controls for population
common start/end dates prevents mismatched cycles
levels alongside rates a high growth rate may begin from a low base

A higher index value after a common base means greater cumulative real growth, not necessarily a larger economy or higher living standard.

Purchasing Power Parity

Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) converts incomes using the relative price of a comparable basket of goods and services. It asks how much currency is needed in each country to buy equivalent purchasing power.

PPP-adjusted real GDP or GNI reduces distortions from market exchange rates and different price levels, making international comparisons of material output or income more meaningful.

PPP is an estimate based on a representative basket. It does not remove differences in inequality, product quality, informal activity or non-material wellbeing.

Positive and negative growth

Growth rate Meaning for real GDP
positive real GDP is higher than in the comparison period
zero real GDP is unchanged
negative real GDP is lower: the economy contracted

A positive rate that falls from 4% to 1% is slower growth, not contraction. A negative rate means the level of real GDP fell during that period.

Do not confuse a fall in the growth rate with a fall in real GDP. The sign of the rate determines whether output rose or fell.

Identifying a recession

In this syllabus, a recession is two consecutive quarters of negative real GDP growth. Both adjacent quarterly growth rates must be below zero.

A recession can reduce income, consumption, profits, investment and tax receipts while increasing unemployment and welfare spending. Its scale depends on depth, duration, policy response and affected sectors.

One negative quarter is a contraction but does not satisfy this two-quarter definition. Disinflation or lower positive growth alone is not a recession.

Limits of GDP and GNI comparisons

Limitation Distortion
population totals do not show output per person
inflation and exchange rates nominal/currency figures may misstate real purchasing power
income distribution an average can rise while many households gain little
informal, unpaid and subsistence activity valuable output may be unrecorded
composition and ownership output may generate income that flows abroad
quality of life and sustainability health, leisure, environment and depleted resources are omitted

Use real per-capita PPP data and supporting social/environmental indicators, while recognising that measurement quality and national conditions differ.

GDP is useful for market output and change; its limitations do not make it worthless or a direct measure of happiness.

National happiness and wellbeing

Wellbeing indicators may include self-reported life satisfaction alongside health, education, employment, security, relationships, environment, leisure and material living standards.

Higher real income can raise subjective happiness by meeting needs, reducing financial insecurity and widening choices. The gain may weaken at higher incomes, and distribution, working conditions, health, freedom and environment can outweigh the income effect.

A correlation between income and happiness does not prove income caused the change. Country averages can hide unequal experiences and cultural differences in survey responses.

Inflation, deflation and disinflation

Term Price-level movement Inflation rate
inflation average price level rises positive
disinflation average price level still rises, but more slowly positive but falling
deflation average price level falls negative

If inflation falls from 6% to 2%, prices are still rising and the price level is higher. Only a negative inflation rate indicates deflation.

A fall in one product's price is not economy-wide deflation; the concept concerns a sustained fall in the general price level.

Calculating CPI inflation

Select a representative basket, measure household expenditure shares as weights, collect prices, set a base-year index (usually 100), and combine price relatives using the weights.

For weighted percentage changes: inflation=(weight×percentage price change)/100inflation=\sum(weight\times percentage\ price\ change)/100. Between index values: inflation=(CPItCPIt1)/CPIt1×100inflation=(CPI_t-CPI_{t-1})/CPI_{t-1}\times100.

With 80% spent on an item rising 25% and 20% on an item rising 20%, inflation is (80×25+20×20)/100=24%(80\times25+20\times20)/100=24\%.

Weights represent expenditure shares, so a large price rise in a low-weight item may have less CPI impact than a small rise in a high-weight item.

Limits of the CPI

Limitation Why measured inflation may differ from experience
representative basket no single basket matches every household
fixed/lagged weights spending patterns and substitution change
quality and new goods price comparisons may mix quality change with inflation
housing and regional differences costs vary by tenure and place
outlet and sampling choices observed prices may miss discounts or channels

Regularly update items and weights so new products and changed consumption patterns enter, while obsolete items leave. This improves representation but cannot remove household-specific differences.

CPI is an average measure, not the exact change in every person's cost of living.

Producer prices as an inflation signal

A producer or wholesale price index measures changes in prices received by producers or paid for inputs at an earlier stage of production.

Rising input or factory-gate prices can increase firms' costs and later feed into consumer prices if firms pass them on. Falling producer prices may signal weaker future cost pressure.

The PPI is an indicator, not a certain forecast. Margins, productivity, contracts, taxes, exchange rates and demand determine whether and when producer-price changes reach the CPI.

Three causes of inflation

Cause Mechanism
demand-pull AD rises faster than productive capacity, bidding up the price level
cost-push input costs rise or SRAS falls; firms raise prices as real output falls
excessive money-supply growth sustained money growth beyond real-output growth supports excessive nominal spending

Trace the initiating change through AD or SRAS and state conditions. Wage growth can be demand-pull through consumption and cost-push through labour costs; context decides which chain dominates.

A one-off price rise raises the price level but need not cause continuing inflation unless it feeds into expectations, wages, costs or demand.

Three causes of deflation

Cause AD/AS mechanism
falling AD consumption, investment, government spending or net exports fall, lowering output and price level
increasing AS lower costs or higher productivity shift supply right, lowering prices while potentially raising output
falling money supply weaker credit and nominal spending reduce AD

Demand-deficient deflation is often damaging because output and employment fall. Supply-driven price falls can accompany higher real output and real income.

Do not assume all deflation has the same welfare effect; identify whether demand contracted or productive supply expanded.

Effects of inflation and deflation

Area Inflation Deflation
consumers/workers purchasing power falls if income lags; borrowers may gain real purchasing power may rise, but jobs/incomes can fall
government nominal tax receipts may rise; debt's real value may fall receipts may fall; real debt burden and welfare spending may rise
firms/investment uncertainty and costs can reduce investment delayed spending and rising real debt can reduce profits/investment
distribution fixed-income savers may lose; debtors may gain creditors may gain; debtors bear heavier real burdens
competitiveness/current account faster domestic inflation can weaken exports and encourage imports lower relative prices may improve competitiveness, unless recession weakens trade

Impact depends on expected versus unexpected change, wage/indexation, cause, rate, duration, indebtedness, spare capacity and trading partners' inflation.

Disinflation is not deflation: slower positive inflation may reduce uncertainty without the debt and delayed-spending mechanisms of falling prices.

Measuring ILO unemployment

Under the ILO measure, an unemployed person is without work, has actively sought work in the previous four weeks and is available to start within the next two weeks. A labour-force survey identifies people meeting these conditions.

unemployment rate=unemployed/labour force×100unemployment\ rate=unemployed/labour\ force\times100. The labour force is employed plus unemployed people, not the total population.

Economically inactive people are outside the labour force and therefore are not counted as unemployed unless they meet the active-search and availability conditions.

Five causes of unemployment

Type Cause
frictional temporary search while moving between jobs
seasonal predictable changes in labour demand during the year
structural lasting mismatch of skills, occupation or location as the economy changes
demand deficient falling AD reduces output and firms' demand for labour
real-wage inflexibility real wages remain above the market-clearing level, leaving labour supply above demand

Identify the labour-market mechanism, not only the industry. A recession points to demand deficiency; technology can create structural unemployment when displaced workers cannot readily fill new jobs.

Frictional unemployment is not caused by deficient demand; it can exist even with many vacancies because matching takes time.

Effects of unemployment

Group/area Likely effect
consumers and workers lower income, skills loss, insecurity and poorer health/living standards
firms weaker demand, but a larger labour pool may reduce recruitment pressure
public finances lower income/consumption tax and higher welfare spending
resource use and PPF economy operates inside its PPF; actual output below potential
society poverty, inequality, crime, ill health and social exclusion may rise

Long unemployment can erode human capital and employability, turning a cyclical loss into a more persistent structural problem.

The unemployment rate alone does not reveal duration, regional concentration, underemployment or who bears the costs.

Unemployment and underemployment

Status Work position Unmet labour supply
unemployed no job; actively seeking and available wants a job
underemployed has a job wants more hours or work better using skills/experience

A graduate in a job that does not require their skills may be skill-underemployed. A part-time worker wanting and available for more hours may be time-underemployed.

Underemployment is not included in the headline unemployed count because the person is employed; both can show unused labour capacity.

Reading labour-market rates together

Rate Numerator Denominator
employment rate employed people relevant working-age population
unemployment rate unemployed people labour force
inactivity rate people neither employed nor unemployed relevant working-age population

A lower unemployment rate can mean people found work, but it can also mean unemployed people became inactive. A higher employment rate is stronger evidence of increased use of labour, though population composition and underemployment still matter.

These rates do not necessarily sum to 100 because unemployment uses the labour force as its denominator while employment/inactivity rates commonly use working-age population.

Net migration and the labour market

net migration=immigrationemigrationnet\ migration=immigration-emigration. Positive net migration means more people arrive than leave.

Channel Possible employment/unemployment effect
labour supply more workers can fill shortages, but competition may initially raise unemployment
aggregate demand migrants consume goods/services, encouraging firms to expand employment
skills/productivity complementary skills can raise productivity and job creation; mismatches can persist
public services and tax workers pay tax but population growth also raises service demand

Net migration does not mechanically raise or lower unemployment. The result depends on migrants' participation, skills, vacancies, demand response, location and time.

Balance-of-payments accounts

Account Records
current account trade in goods, trade in services, primary income and secondary income
capital account capital transfers and transactions in non-produced, non-financial assets
financial account cross-border asset and liability transactions, including investment and reserves

The balance of payments records all transactions between residents and the rest of the world. Accounting entries balance overall once financial flows, reserves and errors/omissions are included.

A current-account deficit is not the same as an overall balance-of-payments deficit or a government budget deficit.

Trade balance: deficit or surplus

trade balance in goods and services=XMtrade\ balance\ in\ goods\ and\ services=X-M. A surplus is positive because exports exceed imports; a deficit is negative because imports exceed exports.

Calculate each period's balance first, preserving negative signs, then subtract the earlier balance from the later one. Moving from -10bnto10bn to -4bn is a $6bn improvement even though the balance remains in deficit.

The trade balance covers goods and services only. It does not by itself reveal the current-account balance, financial account or fiscal balance.

Current-account deficits and surpluses

current account=trade in goods+trade in services+primary income+secondary incomecurrent\ account=trade\ in\ goods+trade\ in\ services+primary\ income+secondary\ income. A positive total is a surplus; a negative total is a deficit.

A deficit means current-account outflows exceed inflows and must be matched by corresponding financial/capital entries and reserve or error adjustments. A surplus means current-account inflows exceed outflows.

Exports below imports often contribute to a deficit, but income and transfer balances can change the final current-account sign. A current-account deficit is not automatically evidence of an overall payments imbalance.