4.3.2 - Trade and the global economy

Syllabus
2018
Topic
4.3.2
Level
A2

Learning objectives

4.3.21a - Benefits and costs of specialisation and trade in the international comparativeBenefits and costs of specialisation and trade in the international comparative context. advantage4.3.21b - theory of comparative advantage: • the distinction between absolute and comparativeThe theory of comparative advantage:; the distinction between absolute and comparative advantage; assumptions underlying the theory of comparative advantage; limitations of the theory of comparative advantage.4.3.22a - Factors influencing patterns of trade between countries and causes volume of world ofFactors influencing patterns of trade between countries and causes volume of world of changes in these patterns: trade; impact of emerging economies; changes in comparative advantage; growth in trading blocs and bilateral trading agreements; changes in relative exchange rates; changes in protectionism between countries.4.3.22b - Changes in trade flows between countries, and the reasons for these changesChanges in trade flows between countries, and the reasons for these changes.4.3.23a - Understanding and calculation of the terms of tradeUnderstanding and calculation of the terms of trade.4.3.23b - Factors influencing a country's terms of trade, changes in: • relative inflation ratesFactors influencing a country's terms of trade, changes in:; relative inflation rates; relative productivity rates; relative labour costs; the exchange rate; the prices of imports and exports.4.3.23c - impact of changes in a country's terms of trade on: • export revenues • livingThe impact of changes in a country's terms of trade on:; export revenues; living standards; balance of trade.4.3.24a - role of the World Trade Organization (WTO) in trade liberalisation and liberalisation.The role of the World Trade Organization (WTO) in trade liberalisation and liberalisation. trading blocs4.3.24b - Types of trading blocs: • free-trade areas • customs unions • common markets • economicTypes of trading blocs:; free-trade areas; customs unions; common markets; economic and monetary unions.4.3.24c - Costs and benefits of membership of a trading bloc: • trade creation • trade diversionCosts and benefits of membership of a trading bloc:; trade creation; trade diversion; costs and prices; economies of scale; transaction costs; movement of factors of production.4.3.24d - Possible conflicts between trading blocs and the WTOPossible conflicts between trading blocs and the WTO.4.3.25a - Reasons for restrictions on free trade: free trade • to protect infant and geriatricReasons for restrictions on free trade: free trade; to protect infant and geriatric industries; to protect domestic industries and employment; to protect national security; to prevent dumping; to correct a deficit on the current account of the balance of payments; to raise revenue.4.3.25b - Types of restrictions on free trade: • tariffs • quotas • non-tariff barriers •Types of restrictions on free trade:; tariffs; quotas; non-tariff barriers; subsidies to domestic producers.4.3.25c - Impact of protectionist policies on: • consumers • producers • governments • livingImpact of protectionist policies on:; consumers; producers; governments; living standards; equality.

Why countries specialise and trade

International specialisation means concentrating resources on goods and services a country can produce at relatively low opportunity cost, then trading for other output. When comparative costs differ, specialisation and exchange can raise total output and consumption possibilities.

Possible benefit Causal route Possible cost or limit
higher world output and consumption resources move towards comparative advantage gains depend on acceptable terms of trade and continuing demand
economies of scale and lower unit cost access to a larger market expands output concentration can create market power or dependence on a narrow export base
more choice and competitive pressure imports widen supply and challenge domestic firms import-competing firms may contract, causing structural unemployment
access to inputs, skills and technology trade connects producers to foreign resources and ideas long supply chains increase exposure to external shocks
export income and growth stronger net exports can raise aggregate demand and investment transport and production may create environmental external costs

A country can gain overall while particular workers, regions or firms lose. The size and distribution of the gain depend on factor mobility, adjustment support, market power, trade barriers and the prices at which exports exchange for imports.

Specialisation is not the same as self-sufficiency or producing only one item. A rise in trade does not by itself prove that every household is better off.

Absolute and comparative advantage

Absolute advantage means producing more output with the same resources. Comparative advantage means producing at a lower opportunity cost. Trade gains depend on comparative, not absolute, advantage.

Maximum output with the same resources Wheat Cloth Opportunity cost of 1 wheat Opportunity cost of 1 cloth
Country A 12 6 0.5 cloth 2 wheat
Country B 8 8 1 cloth 1 wheat

Country A has comparative advantage in wheat because 0.5 cloth is sacrificed rather than 1. Country B has comparative advantage in cloth because 1 wheat is sacrificed rather than 2. If the exchange rate lies between these opportunity-cost ratios, both can consume beyond their pre-trade possibilities.

The simple model assumes two countries and two goods, constant opportunity costs, fixed and fully employed resources, factors mobile within but not between countries, no transport costs or trade barriers, and homogeneous products.

Real gains may be reduced by transport and adjustment costs, changing technology and comparative advantage, economies of scale, imperfect competition, immobile labour, unequal distribution and adverse terms of trade. Equal opportunity-cost ratios give no comparative-advantage basis for specialisation.

What changes world trade patterns

A trade pattern describes who trades with whom and the product and service composition of those flows. The volume of world trade is the quantity traded; its value can also change because prices or exchange rates change.

Specified factor Route to a changed pattern or volume
growth of emerging economies rising output and incomes expand their exports, import demand and share of world trade
changing comparative advantage productivity, skills, resources or costs redirect specialisation and sourcing
trading blocs and bilateral agreements lower internal barriers redirect and often expand trade between partners
relative exchange-rate changes alter foreign-currency prices and competitiveness, subject to demand responsiveness and contracts
changing protectionism tariffs, quotas, subsidies and non-tariff barriers alter relative prices and market access

The drivers interact. An emerging economy may gain comparative advantage through productivity growth, join an agreement that lowers barriers, and then become a larger supplier in regional value chains.

A higher money value of trade need not mean a higher physical volume: commodity-price inflation alone can raise the value. A bilateral gain can also be offset by trade diverted from a lower-cost non-member.

Reading changes in trade flows

A trade flow is an export or import moving between particular countries. A useful explanation identifies the direction, partner, product or service, and whether the evidence measures value, volume or share.

Observed change Questions that identify the reason
bilateral exports rise Did partner income, market access, relative price competitiveness or supply capacity change?
imports switch supplier Did comparative costs, exchange rates, transport costs, quality, sanctions or bloc preferences change?
services replace goods in exports Did skills, technology, productivity or global demand change?
trade value rises but share falls Did prices rise while the partner or world market grew faster?

A complete causal chain links the shock to relative cost or demand, then to competitiveness or market access, and finally to the value, volume, composition or destination of trade.

Do not infer causation from two movements alone. Exchange rates, income, commodity prices and policy can change together, and the effect may be delayed by contracts and low short-run elasticities.

Calculating the terms of trade

The terms of trade index compares the average price of a country's exports with the average price of its imports. It measures the import purchasing power of a unit of exports, not the quantities traded.

$Terms\ of\ trade=\dfrac{index\ of\ export\ prices}{index\ of\ import\ prices}\times100$

If the export-price index is 142.3 and the import-price index is 121.3, the terms of trade are 142.3/121.3×100=117.3142.3/121.3\times100=117.3 (1 d.p.). Relative to a base of 100, export prices have risen more than import prices, so the terms of trade have improved.

If both indices begin at 100 and export prices fall 4.8% while import prices fall 3.1%, the new index is 95.2/96.9×100=98.2595.2/96.9\times100=98.25: a deterioration even though both prices fell.

An improved terms of trade does not automatically improve the balance of trade. Export revenue and import spending also depend on quantities and price elasticities of demand.

What moves a country's terms of trade

The terms of trade improve when export prices rise relative to import prices and worsen when import prices rise relative to export prices. Each factor matters through one or both price indices.

Change, ceteris paribus Likely price route Likely terms-of-trade effect
higher domestic inflation than trading partners domestic export prices tend to rise relatively improvement if passed into export prices; competitiveness may fall
faster productivity growth or lower relative labour costs unit cost and export prices can fall deterioration if firms pass lower costs into export prices
currency appreciation imports become cheaper in domestic currency and exports may become dearer abroad improvement, depending on pricing and pass-through
currency depreciation imports become dearer and exports may become cheaper abroad deterioration, depending on pricing and pass-through
higher world price of a country's main exports export-price index rises improvement
higher world price of essential imports import-price index rises deterioration

The effect is conditional on the trade basket, market power, contract currency, firms' pricing decisions and the duration of the change. For a commodity exporter, a world commodity-price movement may dominate domestic cost changes.

Lower production cost can improve competitiveness while worsening the terms of trade if export prices fall. Competitiveness and terms of trade are related but not identical.

Consequences of a terms-of-trade change

An improvement in the terms of trade means a given quantity of exports can purchase more imports; a deterioration means it can purchase fewer. The welfare and trade-balance effects are not automatic because quantities respond to prices.

Outcome If terms of trade improve Why the result remains conditional
export revenue higher export prices may raise revenue revenue can fall if export demand is sufficiently price elastic
living standards imports become cheaper relative to exports, raising real purchasing power job losses in less competitive export industries may offset the gain
balance of trade each export unit finances more imports export volumes may fall and import volumes may rise, worsening the balance

A deterioration reverses the purchasing-power effect, but may make exports more price competitive. If export and import quantities respond strongly enough, higher net export volume can offset the less favourable price ratio.

Terms of trade use price indices; the balance of trade uses export and import values. Never treat an index improvement as proof of higher export volume, revenue or national welfare.

How the WTO supports trade liberalisation

The World Trade Organization (WTO) provides a multilateral framework in which member governments negotiate, apply and review rules intended to make international trade more open and predictable.

WTO role Link to liberalisation
forum for negotiations members can agree reductions in tariffs and non-tariff barriers
common trade rules commitments constrain arbitrary discrimination and make market access more predictable
monitoring and review members' trade policies and commitments can be scrutinised
dispute settlement members can challenge alleged rule breaches through an agreed process rather than unilateral retaliation

Liberalisation can be slow because agreements require negotiation among members with conflicting interests. Enforcement depends on members bringing cases and complying with outcomes; WTO membership does not eliminate protectionism.

The WTO is not the World Bank and it does not set one global tariff. Its role is to provide negotiated rules and processes for member governments.

From a free-trade area to monetary union

Trading blocs differ by how much policy and factor-market integration members share. Each deeper form normally includes the central feature of the preceding form.

Type Internal trade barriers External trade policy Factor movement Monetary integration
free-trade area removed or reduced between members each member keeps its own not required not required
customs union removed or reduced common external tariff or policy not required not required
common market removed or reduced common external policy labour and capital can move more freely not required
economic and monetary union removed or reduced coordinated/common freer movement integrated economic policy and a common currency/monetary policy

A common external tariff identifies a customs union; free movement of labour and capital identifies a common market; a shared currency and central monetary authority identify monetary union.

A trade agreement does not automatically create free factor movement or a shared currency. Classify a bloc from the institutions it actually shares, not from its name or size.

Trading-bloc membership: gains and trade-offs

Trade creation occurs when removing an internal barrier replaces higher-cost domestic production with lower-cost imports from a member. Trade diversion occurs when preference shifts imports from a lower-cost non-member to a higher-cost member.

Membership channel Potential benefit Potential cost or condition
trade creation lower resource cost, prices and greater consumer surplus import-competing producers and workers may lose
trade diversion member trade expands world efficiency and tariff revenue can fall when a cheaper outsider is displaced
larger market firms can expand and gain economies of scale dominant firms may gain market power; weaker firms may exit
fewer border and currency frictions lower bureaucracy, uncertainty and transaction costs compliance with common rules can impose adjustment or sovereignty costs
movement of labour and capital vacancies, skills and investment can be matched across members regions may lose scarce workers or face pressure on housing and services

Net benefit depends on the size of internal barrier reductions, the common external barrier, cost differences, demand elasticities, distance, market competition, factor mobility and how adjustment gains and losses are distributed.

More intra-bloc trade is not sufficient evidence of a welfare gain: it may reflect either trade creation or trade diversion. Compare the post-membership supplier with both the former domestic producer and the lowest-cost non-member.

Why trading blocs can conflict with WTO aims

The WTO promotes multilateral, rules-based liberalisation, whereas a trading bloc gives preferential access to its members. Regional integration can support freer trade internally while discriminating against outsiders.

Possible conflict Mechanism
preferential tariffs members receive lower barriers than comparable non-members, challenging non-discrimination
trade diversion bloc preference can replace a more efficient outside supplier
common external barriers a bloc may protect its enlarged market or use standards and rules of origin restrictively
bargaining rivalry large blocs can form competing negotiating positions and trigger retaliation or fragmented rules

There is no necessary conflict: a regional agreement can remove substantial internal barriers, build support for wider liberalisation and operate within WTO conditions. The judgement depends on whether it creates new trade or mainly raises discrimination against non-members.

Trading blocs are not automatically prohibited by the WTO. The tension is between preferential regional treatment and non-discriminatory multilateral liberalisation, not between all regional cooperation and WTO membership.

Why governments restrict free trade

Stated reason Intended mechanism Main limitation
infant industry temporary protection allows a new firm or sector to learn and gain scale governments may protect firms with no future comparative advantage
geriatric industry gives a declining sector time to restructure protection may delay unavoidable adjustment
domestic industry and employment reduces import competition and supports domestic output/jobs higher input prices and retaliation can destroy jobs elsewhere
national security preserves capacity in strategically essential goods the definition of strategic can be widened for political protection
prevent dumping counters imports sold below a relevant normal value or cost low price alone does not prove predatory dumping
current-account deficit restrains import spending retaliation, low elasticities or dearer imported inputs can offset the effect
government revenue a tariff raises tax per unit imported revenue falls if the import base contracts strongly

A reason explains the policy aim, not whether the restriction is efficient. Evaluation compares the targeted benefit with consumer costs, resource misallocation, administrative cost and the risk of foreign retaliation.

Protection is not automatically permanent or successful. An infant-industry case requires a credible route to future competitiveness and a disciplined exit from support.

Tariffs, quotas and other trade restrictions

A protectionist policy changes the price, quantity, cost or administrative conditions of trade to favour domestic activity or limit imports.

Restriction How it works Key incidence
tariff tax on an imported good raises its domestic price government receives tariff revenue while consumers pay more
quota legal limit on import quantity restricts supply quota rent goes to whoever holds the right to import
non-tariff barrier standards, licensing, procurement or administrative rules raise the cost or difficulty of entry effect depends on whether the rule corrects a genuine standard or disguises discrimination
subsidy to domestic producers lowers domestic firms' cost or supports their revenue taxpayers fund it; output and exports may rise without an import tax

A tariff fixes the tax rate while import quantity responds; a quota fixes the maximum quantity while the price and quota rent respond. A subsidy supports domestic supply but does not directly make the imported product pay a tax.

Not every product standard is protectionist: a rule may address safety or information failure. It becomes a trade barrier when its design or application unnecessarily restricts foreign suppliers.

Who gains and loses from protectionism

Protection changes prices, output, trade and income distribution. Its effects must be traced separately for consumers, producers and government before judging living standards or equality.

Stakeholder/outcome Likely effect Why it may differ
consumers higher prices and less choice reduce consumer surplus some may gain if protected employment or income rises
protected domestic producers higher price/output can raise producer surplus and employment weaker competition can reduce efficiency and innovation
other producers some gain demand; users of protected imported inputs face higher cost exporters may be harmed by retaliation
government tariffs raise revenue; subsidies require expenditure quota rent may not reach government and administration has a cost
living standards lower purchasing power and world efficiency can reduce material welfare strategic capacity or temporary adjustment gains may offset some cost
equality protected low-income jobs or redistributed revenue can reduce inequality regressive price rises and gains to owners/quota holders can increase it

Across countries, widespread protection can distort comparative advantage, reduce specialisation and world output, raise prices and provoke retaliation. Domestic gains may therefore be transferred from consumers or foreign producers rather than created.

The result depends on the instrument, duration, market structure, demand and supply elasticities, use of revenue, ownership of protected firms and retaliation. A tariff diagram shows surplus transfers and deadweight loss, not the full dynamic or distributional effect.