(d) Analyse one advantage and one disadvantage for Klar of having ethical objectives.
To support its ethical objectives of being environmentally friendly, Klar has decided to use reusable glass bottles instead of plastic containers. With such a decision, Klar can gain on brand image and reputation, which might lead to an increased customer base and support from government and environmental groups. A growing trend among consumers is consume products that will not damage the environment. However, products that do not damage the environment usually cost more.
If Klar wants to support the environment by using glass bottles, they must do one of two things:
- Pass the higher cost on to consumers. However, with price still a determinant component in choice for most of the customers, under this option Klar must persuade price-conscious consumers that the more expensive Klar products are worth it because it helps protect the environment or Klar runs the risk of losing market share, lowering profits, and weakening returns.
- Absorb the higher cost of the containers themselves, lowering margins and lowering return on investment (ROI). However, shareholders of Klar may object to this approach, regardless of how much good this approach does for the environment.
The issue for Klar is one of time horizon. Though some consumers are getting more conscientious about pollution issues and are probably more open to adopt responsible consumption habits, for the majority of consumers, price is still what matters. In the long run, however, if consumer trends continue, most consumers will probably become conscientious about environmentally friendly products.
Balance, on this question, is more than analysing the binarity of good reputation/image versus higher cost. Balance comes from deepening their response by extending their reasoning. For example,
- bringing into account the fact that for most consumers, price is the determining factor
- giving consideration to the time element (short-term versus long-term)
- extending the higher cost implications out to different stakeholders groups, such as shareholders
- accept any other relevant extension.