Do not agree with claim
Explanation I: In experiment 1, the moles of CaCO_3=50.0 g / 100.09 g / mol=0.500 mol CaCO_3. If the reaction had gone to completion, 0.500 mol of CO_2 would have been produced. From part (a) only 0.0115 mol was produced. Hence, the student's claim was false.
Explanation II: The two different experiments (one with 50.0 g of CaCO_3 and one with 100.0 g of CaCO_3 ) reached the same constant, final pressure of 1.04 atm. Since increasing the amount of reactant did not produce more product, there is no way that all of the CaCO_3 reacted. Instead, an equilibrium condition has been achieved and there must be some solid CaCO_3 in the container.
1 point is earned for disagreement with the claim and for a correct justification using stoichiometry or
a discussion of the creation of an equilibrium condition.